Cardinal Pell: Liberal intolerance ‘must be opposed’

hellhathno

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2009
Messages
65
Good article from Alive!

Alive!
 


Telemachus

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 8, 2004
Messages
6,480
Website
en.wikipedia.org
This ties in a lot with an essay by Jim Kalb called "The Tyranny of Liberalism"

http://turnabout.ath.cx:8000/node/25

the spirit of that article is as follows, This comes from an interview from ZENIT - A catholic journal based from Rome,.

Q: How can an ideology of freedom become tyrannical?

Kalb: Equal freedom is an open-ended standard that makes unlimited demands when taken seriously.

For example, it views non-liberal standards as oppressive, because they limit equal freedom. Liberal government wants to protect us from oppression, so it tries to eradicate those standards from more and more areas of life.

The attempt puts liberal government at odds with natural human tendencies. If the way someone acts seems odd to me, and I look at him strangely, that helps construct the social world he's forced to live in. He will find that oppressive. Liberal government can't accept that, so it eventually feels compelled to supervise all my attitudes about how people live and how I express them.

The end result is a comprehensive system of control over all human relations run by an expert elite responsible only to itself. That, of course, is tyranny.
 

hellhathno

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2009
Messages
65
This ties in a lot with an essay by Jim Kalb called "The Tyranny of Liberalism"

http://turnabout.ath.cx:8000/node/25

the spirit of that article is as follows, This comes from an interview from ZENIT - A catholic journal based from Rome,.

Q: How can an ideology of freedom become tyrannical?

Kalb: Equal freedom is an open-ended standard that makes unlimited demands when taken seriously.

For example, it views non-liberal standards as oppressive, because they limit equal freedom. Liberal government wants to protect us from oppression, so it tries to eradicate those standards from more and more areas of life.

The attempt puts liberal government at odds with natural human tendencies. If the way someone acts seems odd to me, and I look at him strangely, that helps construct the social world he's forced to live in. He will find that oppressive. Liberal government can't accept that, so it eventually feels compelled to supervise all my attitudes about how people live and how I express them.

The end result is a comprehensive system of control over all human relations run by an expert elite responsible only to itself. That, of course, is tyranny.
+1
 

theObserver@hotmail.com

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Messages
2,395
And he warned that “modern liberalism has strong totalitarian tendencies.” It implies that “institutions and associations exist only with the permission of the state, and they must abide the dictates of the state.”
Well, yes institutions must abide the dictates of the state. Especially when a institution has a record of sexual abuse, cover ups and corruption.

Cardinal Pell made his remarks amid growing concern in Ireland that Justice Minister Dermot Ahern’s bill on “civil unions” will prove to be a massive attack on religious freedom and Christian sexual morality.
How is civil unions a 'massive attack on religious freedom? Unless it's a massive attack on priestly authority to dictate how humans may choose to live their lives. Morality can only exist where there is freedom of choice.

That includes secularising the services Church agencies provide to society. “Part of the logic in attacking the freedom of the Church to serve others is to undermine the witness these services give to powerful Christian convictions,” said the Cardinal. “The goal is to neutralise this witness to the reality of Christian revelation.”
So these to motivation behind these catholic services is the prorogation of their ideology to the weak and vulnerable and any attempt to provide additional secular services is then an attack on the catholic church?

A central issue for modern culture, he argued, is the meaning of human autonomy (independence) and especially sexual freedom.

“The message from the earliest days of the sexual revolution,” he said, “was that limits on sexual autonomy will not be tolerated.” And “this is generating the pressures against religion in public life.”
No sh*t.

Faced with the secularist worldview, he argued, “Christians have to recover their genius for showing that there are better ways to live and to build a good society—ways that respect freedom, empower individuals, and transform communities.”
Ahahahahahahahahah.
 

theObserver@hotmail.com

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Messages
2,395
This ties in a lot with an essay by Jim Kalb called "The Tyranny of Liberalism"

http://turnabout.ath.cx:8000/node/25

the spirit of that article is as follows, This comes from an interview from ZENIT - A catholic journal based from Rome,.

Q: How can an ideology of freedom become tyrannical?

Kalb: Equal freedom is an open-ended standard that makes unlimited demands when taken seriously.

For example, it views non-liberal standards as oppressive, because they limit equal freedom. Liberal government wants to protect us from oppression, so it tries to eradicate those standards from more and more areas of life.

The attempt puts liberal government at odds with natural human tendencies. If the way someone acts seems odd to me, and I look at him strangely, that helps construct the social world he's forced to live in. He will find that oppressive. Liberal government can't accept that, so it eventually feels compelled to supervise all my attitudes about how people live and how I express them.

The end result is a comprehensive system of control over all human relations run by an expert elite responsible only to itself. That, of course, is tyranny.
That last sentence appearing in a roman catholic journal just broke my irony meter.
 

Lao-Tse

Active member
Joined
Dec 26, 2008
Messages
162
Interesting that Mr. Kalb is keen on "oppressing" and "forcing" people whose
lifefestyle he finds "odd". I find it bizarre that anyone would want to spend an hour
in a Church listen to magic rituals said in Latin but I don't want to ban them from doing it.
 

hellhathno

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2009
Messages
65
Interesting that Mr. Kalb is keen on "oppressing" and "forcing" people whose
lifefestyle he finds "odd". I find it bizarre that anyone would want to spend an hour
in a Church listen to magic rituals said in Latin but I don't want to ban them from doing it.
But we choose to listen to god's word because we know we will be freed from satan's oppression. Liberalism oppresses christianity when it comes to this point.
 

Mitsui

Active member
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Messages
118
An amazing, irony-free instance of a pot calling a kettle black.

I'm aware of no instance in which the Catholic Church, when left free to do so, did not attempt to subject non-believers to its strictures, either openly (when that was possible) or covertly (when it was not).

We are looking here, methinks, at yet another example of that peculiar Catholic use of language where "freedom" = the freedom to obey Church rules and "tyranny" = the freedom to decide for oneself.

There's a fascinating book to be written someday on the RC church's use (or - by anyone else's standards - abuse) of language, should some linguist have a mind twisted enough and a stomach strong enough to plumb its depths.
 
M

MrFunkyBoogaloo

well, yes institutions must abide the dictates of the state. Especially when a institution has a record of sexual abuse, cover ups and corruption.


How is civil unions a 'massive attack on religious freedom? Unless it's a massive attack on priestly authority to dictate how humans may choose to live their lives. morality can only exist where there is freedom of choice.


so these to motivation behind these catholic services is the prorogation of their ideology to the weak and vulnerable and any attempt to provide additional secular services is then an attack on the catholic church?



No sh*t.


Ahahahahahahahahah.
+1

an amazing, irony-free instance of a pot calling a kettle black.

I'm aware of no instance in which the catholic church, when left free to do so, did not attempt to subject non-believers to its strictures, either openly (when that was possible) or covertly (when it was not).

We are looking here, methinks, at yet another example of that peculiar catholic use of language where "freedom" = the freedom to obey church rules and "tyranny" = the freedom to decide for oneself.

There's a fascinating book to be written someday on the rc church's use (or - by anyone else's standards - abuse) of language, should some linguist have a mind twisted enough and a stomach strong enough to plumb its depths.
+1
 

Andrew49

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
6,019
Twitter
AndrewSB49
Melbourne's Catholic Church has released the names of 29 priests it acknowledges are guilty of child sex abuse. It comes the same week as an inquiry heard there was a systematic cover up of child sexual abuse, which went on for decades. Cardinal George Pell is Australia's most senior Catholic, and this week he fronted a Victorian inquiry into sex abuse, confessing to the sins of the Church. He says the systemic cover up allowed paedophile priests to prey on innocent children, and the fear of scandal led to the cover up. LINK

List of 26 names:

Anthony Bongiorno
John Byrne
Peter Chalk
David Daniel
Bernard Day
Anthony Eames
Nazareno Fasciale
Desmond Gannon
Michael Glennon
Jack Gubbels
Barry Gwillim
Penn Jones
Bernie Mackin
Terry Merivale
Syd Morey
John O'Callaghan
Kevin O'Donnell
Tom O'Keefe
Paul Pavlou
Dominic Phillips
Ronald Pickering
Terence Pidoto
Victor Rubeo
Peter Searson
Ray Whitehouse

Ballarat Bishop Ronald Mulkearns and former Melbourne Archbishop Frank Little deliberately (and with malice) destroyed documents to hide abuse cases. Pell defended his accompanying Fr Gerald Ridsdale, one of Australia's worst paedophiles, in court hearings. That one priest raped 9 children. Pell admitted 620 children were raped by clergy over the past eight decades.

Pell also refused point-blank to condemn the rapists and their enablers.
 

LamportsEdge

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
21,694
Kilbarry1 will be on in minute to explain how it was all the action of one rogue kangaroo dressed up as a priest, apparently...
 

Nipper

Well-known member
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
2,526
Is Alive still going. I haven't had that through the door in a while?
 

LamportsEdge

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
21,694
Ireland's 'wideliest distributed' magazine apparently. Last week they fired an extra 100,000 copies into space so circulation wise things are looking up.
 


New Threads

Popular Threads

Most Replies

Top