Eamon Ryan asked on BBC's HARDTalk - "What will it take to save the Irish economy?"

Joined
Feb 21, 2003
Messages
4,249
Website
www.politics.ie
Twitter
davidcochrane
"Ireland is struggling to convince money markets and the EU that it can avoid financial collapse" was how Stephen Sackur introduced this interview with Eamon Ryan on BBC's HARDTalk programme over the weekend. Sackur goes on to ask "What will it take to save the Irish economy?"

Ryan was asked what it was like being in a government that was "wresting with arguably the worst budget deficit in the industrialised world".

Sackur challenged Ryan asking about the Irish budget deficit representing 1/3 of GDP - Ryan replied by saying that Ireland had experienced "common-or-garden" property bubble. Ryan said Ireland has to make sure the property bubble doesn't happen again.

Ryan said that Ireland had a balance of payments surplus. Ireland is now in "cash positive" position he says.

Eamon Ryan told Sackur that one of the "benefits" is that the property market is now "saner that makes it easier for people to get rental, get a property".

Sackur quotes Nouriel Roubini who in reference to Ireland (as well as Portugal and Greece) says that "debt restructuring may be necessary" - Ryan responds by saying he believes that Roubini has been proven to be true in the past but he (Ryan) doesn't believe that Ireland will have to "avail of such facilities" such as the EU and IMF for a bailout.

Ryan talks about Ireland's cash reserves, referring to the 25bn in the Pension reserve fund as money for a "rainy day" calling it "real money" which has allowed Ireland take the hit from Ireland's banks.

When asked about the plans for the budget, Ryan talks about the need to increase taxes and implement cuts to spending, adding that the "economy is starting to turn anyways".

On the topic of "fairness", Sackur challenges Ryan on public spending cuts and whether it's fair for the people of Ireland to be bearing the brunt of the state of the economy, Sackur asks why bankers and property developers aren't being held to account for causing the crisis. Ryan says he would love to see bankers pay "in their own way, but that's not a realisitic solution". Ryan says changes to the banking system are ahead to ensure people don't think that bankers are seen to get away with it.

Sackur raises Sean Quinn's debts being written off by Anglo querying if that's what can be defined as "fair". Ryan says no person will get special treatment. Sackur challenges that assertion and says he can't find any evidence of any punishment or suffering of bankers or developers, and can't see how they're impoverished. Ryan says the courts and legal system will take action on debts and crime - saying it's the job of the judicial system, not the political system.

Ryan says towards the end of the first half of the interview that the Irish political system is "coming together" to deal with the problems.

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNCdqip_PTo]YouTube - Eamon Ryan HARDtalk Part 1/2[/ame]

The second part of the interview focusses on the Green Party's role in Government, the failure to hold the by-elections in order to "thwart" democracy and the issue of net emigration by Irish nationals from the country.

Sackur asks if Ryan belives it was such a good idea to go into Government with Fianna Fail now that the Greens are "propping up the party and many of the individual people that got Ireland into this mess". Ryan says he was glad that the Green Party went into government to be able to set Ireland in a "greener direction".

Sackur quotes Trevor Sargent who called the merger "an unbelieveably bad decision", Ryan says that Sargent works with him (Ryan) and the 85% of party members who agree with what the party is doing in Government who he says are "operating in the best interests of the country".

Ryan agrees with Sackur during the interview that the Greens are "propping up" Fianna Fail who didn't listen to issues of concern raised about the Irish property market.

Ryan talks about achivements that his role in Government has made, Sackur goes on to challenge him about energy price increases at a time when "the irish economy is on it's knees". Ryan effectively ignores the question, to say that Green policies are working.

Challenged on the by-elections and the delay in them taking place, Sackur says the Government is thwarting the law in avoiding the byelections which should have been run "months and months and months ago" saying that the Government is scared of losing all three byelections and having a wafer thin majority. Ryan says the Government has been a bit busy and distracted with the economic situation.

The end of the interview concerns emigration by irish nationals, Sackur says 25,000 irish people "net" have left the country - Ryan responds by saying Sackur should be "careful" with his figures, saying they're not very clear.

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vTPDynVNqw]YouTube - Eamon Ryan HARDtalk Part 2/2[/ame]
 


Desperate Dan

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 26, 2010
Messages
5,682
Why would any responsible reporter ( I only assume he is) ask a Gob!!!!e like Ryan anything about the economy. A kid in high babies would know more.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

He3

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
17,077
It just gets worse and worse doesn't it.

There isn't €25bn 'real money' in the NPRF. What is the point though? Headless chickens.
 

bokuden

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 23, 2010
Messages
11,250
Is he insane? This is a serious question. I think he's lost his marbles.
 

EvotingMachine0197

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 17, 2006
Messages
8,552
..
Challenged on the by-elections and the delay in them taking place, Sackur says the Government is thwarting the law in avoiding the byelections which should have been run "months and months and months ago" saying that the Government is scared of losing all three byelections and having a wafer thing majority. Ryan says the Government has been a bit busy and distracted with the economic situation.
I could accept the bit busy argument if it wasn't for the fact that they recently took four months holidays.
 

stripey cat

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
2,799
He doesn't do drugs anymore does he? When he put himself forward for president, he said he used to smoke a lot of whaccy baccy, but he gave it up.

He did give it up, didn't he?
 

loner

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 9, 2005
Messages
8,089
This is very interesting stuff---Ryan is a frightening figure--his messianic stance on most things is scary--hope the General Election will put an end to his political carreer---
 

GFlynn

New member
Joined
Feb 22, 2010
Messages
1
Eamon Ryan: Why does he do so much media stuff ( eg PrimeTime last week)? He looks as though he is always struggling to try to make himself believe what he is saying; he sounds like what he really wants to do, is to break down and cry, put his head on the desk and bang his fists against the desk surface repeatedly.
 

Expatriot

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 7, 2009
Messages
4,325
The BBC are lucky they dont depend on the TV licence from us of it would be revoked and the program boycotted by the government. They are not used to being asked straight tough questions. A large portion of our media are doing us no favours by taking it softly on the government. They need to be held to account on the massive errors they have made. The Greens biggest mistake in my book is that they have not walked and their silly ring fencing of issues like parts of education or transports for narrow personal reasons.

RTE would not be allowed to ask such direct questions.
 

bokuden

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 23, 2010
Messages
11,250
I was trying to put my finger on who he reminded me of. Then it hit me... It's Brian Lehihan! Ryan and Lenihan have melded into one!
 

Oppenheimer

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Messages
1,461
It is thwarting the law to not hold the by-elections so not surprising that one cohort of our society, the political class (specifically those in Govt.), would classify the necessary impoverishment of bankers and developers as a legal system issue rather than a political one - why would one part of the cozy cabal take a swipe at another part?
 

Expatriot

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 7, 2009
Messages
4,325
This is very interesting stuff---Ryan is a frightening figure--his messianic stance on most things is scary--hope the General Election will put an end to his political carreer---
That is the frightening thing, I think the Greens actually believe some of the nonsense the government comes out with, at least you can see most of the FF hate saying it and know it is total rubbish. Lenihan can be the same way sometimes, but he looks like his faith is broken now, like a salesman the door keeps closing on.
 

gijoe

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2010
Messages
15,237
It just gets worse and worse doesn't it.

There isn't €25bn 'real money' in the NPRF. What is the point though? Headless chickens.
I think he is telling porkies there. There is I think €11billion in NPRF. Is he adding the circa €12billion borrowed cash that the NTMA have squirreled away to the NPRF money?
 

Expatriot

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 7, 2009
Messages
4,325
I think he is telling porkies there. There is I think €11billion in NPRF. Is he adding the circa €12billion borrowed cash that the NTMA have squirreled away to the NPRF money?
I thought alot of that money already "invested" in bank shares.
- ie flushed down the toilet.
 

stripey cat

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
2,799
In the 1970's a Fianna Fáil government sacked every member of the board of RTÉ.

Senior people working there now can remember that. Of course it has an effect on their thinking.
 

an innocent abroad

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
27,532
O.M.G. watching that interview reminded me of the minister of propaganda during the Iraq invasion, while standing in the city of baghdad, he was asked "if the americans had entered baghdad and in positive spin and a smile on his facecompletely denied the americans had reached the city" as an american tank could be seen in the background"! To quote gormley " planet ryan" and the rest are living on another planet! with lots of little green men and women running around. We should call leinster house The house of damasus, I have never seen so many politicans converted, greens, p.d's. labour to the f.f. modes operandi.
 

Expatriot

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 7, 2009
Messages
4,325
In the 1970's a Fianna Fáil government sacked every member of the board of RTÉ.

Senior people working there now can remember that. Of course it has an effect on their thinking.
I am not sure anyone could make a case for a national broadcaster if it cannot act somewhat independently at a time like this. If politicians come knocking for them again they will have not case to defend themselves.
 


New Threads

Most Replies

Top