Shocking waste of taxpayers money by Galwayc City Council to the tune of €10.5 million

GDPR

1
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
217,782
Late 2006 on a site on the outskirts of Galway City at Keeraun on the Ballymoneen Road, a developer bought a 7.6 acre plot in two sections off a local farmer for €6.5 million. Early 2008, Galway City Council bought the plots off the developer for an eye watering €10.5 million, a cool €4 million in profit for the developer. To date Galway City Council has done nothing with this uber expensive land, had not paid a cent off the €10.5 million loan, instead paying interest only. The sites had been earmarked for social and affordable housing, but instead the latest proposal is for a halting site to address traveller needs. One can only speculate that this would be the most expensive halting site in the world, but of course it's worse than that as this site and others like is costing the City Council €600,000 a year in interest only payments. Serious questions arise as to who in the Council and the Department of Environment sanctioned this eye watering purchase. The site was not accepted into Nama for local authorities, the Land Aggregation Scheme.

A member of the PAC, Marc MacSharry, who are to investigate this matter on Thursday commented that “On the surface it would appear that because a lack of process there is a major loss, it would appear the executive entered into the deal without seeking or receiving the approval of the elected members of the council. It would seem to be an extraordinary premium to be paid for the land by the council and it is clear that someone was caught napping. Under the various acts the Department of the Environment have to sanction all borrowing so we need to know on what basis was this allowed happen.”

What makes such apparent wastage even more galling is that Galway City Council has built zero social houses since 2009 and will not be building any until 2018. What say p.ie, will heads roll over this, will the PAC be able to get to the bottom of this or will it simply be brushed off as 'mistakes were made back then, times are different now, no individual is to blame it is the system and we are putting in place several expensive reviews and consultations to rectify weaknesses in the system :confused:

Multimillion euro land purchase lying idle in Galway | Irish Examiner
No social housing to be built in Galway City until 2018 - Connacht Tribune
 


brughahaha

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2009
Messages
15,406
Our councils are cesspits of unaccountable incompetence corruption and gombeenism ........ the very worst of our Publc services
 

GDPR

1
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
217,782
At €1.38 million an acre, it demonstrates that at the higher echelons of Galway City Council and the Department of Environment, the concept of value for money did not even feature. Like seriously, what were these people thinking:confused: Even it it was developed for social housing, your could add at least €250,000 a unit at say 100 units in total or €25,000,000 to build the things and then probably another 2 million to finish off the place, provide community facilities and such, to bring the total to something like €32 million. The mind boggles.
 

Therightroad

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 12, 2010
Messages
1,158
All Galway City Council official are earning large salaries and will have gold plated defined Benefit Pensions and large lump sums when they retire...there is NO performance management so they can make as many c0ck ups at they wish during their working lifes....thats public service for you!!....Gravvyyy Train!!
 

General Urko

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
15,713
Basically if you make a large Fúck Up you should be sacked and they shouldn't be paid and perked like they are in the first place, it engenders an Apartheidal relationship with ordinary folk - how can it not?
 

enuffisenuff

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 27, 2011
Messages
3,479
I have to take umbrage with the word shocking..theres nothing shocking about it..shocking would be something done right for once in this kip..
 

GDPR

1
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
217,782
I have to take umbrage with the word shocking..theres nothing shocking about it..shocking would be something done right for once in this kip..
Perhaps mildly concerning, and while we're at it perhaps could someone amend Galwayc to just plain old Galway in the thread title.
 

max99

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 22, 2009
Messages
2,834
Heard there was some family connection, with the cesspit in Gal Co Co and the owner of the land... sick country really ... zero accountability ...
 

Lumpy Talbot

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2015
Messages
29,497
Twitter
No
Phil Hogan cancelled proposed inquiries into planning and zoning at local authority level. Apparently there was no need.

I wonder who the developer was that flipped the land to Galway CC for a 4m euro profit and how he was able to guess that Galway CC would be willing to pay such a premium for it.

At least that question is probably going around in the mind of the farmer involved anyway.

There is no corruption in Ireland. Ireland is corruption free because very few people have ever been convicted for it. Therefore Ireland is corruption free.
 

Lumpy Talbot

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2015
Messages
29,497
Twitter
No
Wonder which Galway City Council connection got a new car out of this little lot?
 

Expose the lot of them

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2009
Messages
20,744
Late 2006 on a site on the outskirts of Galway City at Keeraun on the Ballymoneen Road, a developer bought a 7.6 acre plot in two sections off a local farmer for €6.5 million. Early 2008, Galway City Council bought the plots off the developer for an eye watering €10.5 million, a cool €4 million in profit for the developer. To date Galway City Council has done nothing with this uber expensive land, had not paid a cent off the €10.5 million loan, instead paying interest only. The sites had been earmarked for social and affordable housing, but instead the latest proposal is for a halting site to address traveller needs. One can only speculate that this would be the most expensive halting site in the world, but of course it's worse than that as this site and others like is costing the City Council €600,000 a year in interest only payments. Serious questions arise as to who in the Council and the Department of Environment sanctioned this eye watering purchase. The site was not accepted into Nama for local authorities, the Land Aggregation Scheme.

A member of the PAC, Marc MacSharry, who are to investigate this matter on Thursday commented that “On the surface it would appear that because a lack of process there is a major loss, it would appear the executive entered into the deal without seeking or receiving the approval of the elected members of the council. It would seem to be an extraordinary premium to be paid for the land by the council and it is clear that someone was caught napping. Under the various acts the Department of the Environment have to sanction all borrowing so we need to know on what basis was this allowed happen.”

What makes such apparent wastage even more galling is that Galway City Council has built zero social houses since 2009 and will not be building any until 2018. What say p.ie, will heads roll over this, will the PAC be able to get to the bottom of this or will it simply be brushed off as 'mistakes were made back then, times are different now, no individual is to blame it is the system and we are putting in place several expensive reviews and consultations to rectify weaknesses in the system :confused:

Multimillion euro land purchase lying idle in Galway | Irish Examiner
No social housing to be built in Galway City until 2018 - Connacht Tribune
Was Tierney involved?
 

Vega1447

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
5,685
No he left towards the end of 2004. I can't find who was in charge back then, only lists current CEO, Brendan McGrath.

I have emailed Galway CC asking for this info (without saying why).

I'll post any reply here.

So far:

Good afternoon Mr WWWWWW
I have forwarded your email to our Corporate Services Section.Kind regards,
YYYYYY ZZZZZZ
Seirbhís Chustaiméara/Customer Service
Comhairle Cathrach na Gaillimhe/Galway City Council
Halla na Cathrach/City Hall
Bóthar an Choláiste/College RoadGaillimh/Galway

≠=========≠

Good morning VVVVV.

I received the following information regarding the City Managers/Chief Executive from our Corporate Services Section.

Joe Gavin - Galway City Manager
1994 - 2000

John Tierney - Galway City Manager
2001 - 2004

Joe MacGrath - Galway City Manager
2005 - 2010

Joe O'Neill - Acting Galway City Manager
2011 - 2013

Brendan McGrath - Galway City Manager/Chief Executive
2013 - to date

The names of the various Director of Services over the period are not readily available as there have been a lot of changes over the years.
Hope this information is of some assistance.
 
Last edited:


New Threads

Most Replies

Top