• Due to a glitch in the old vBulletin software, some users were "banned" when they tried to change their passwords at the end of February. This does not apply after the site was converted to Xenforo. If you were affected by this, please contact us.




What does Fianna Fail stand for?

Raketemensch

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
3,128
This is a genuine request from FF supporters to explain what they see as the values or ideology of the party and why they follow it. What makes you a 'Fianna Fail sort of person'? It can be difficult for non-fans like myself to understand what exactly FF is supposed to represent and here is an opportunity to get it out in the open. If it gets off the ground at all, the thread will no doubt disintegrate into abuse and childishness but lets try to keep it clean for as long as possible, I think it could be of interest for both those who are for and those against.
 


Raketemensch

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
3,128
Silence speaks volumes

Thanks for that. I was hoping for more responses from FFers but their silence speaks volumes. They don't know what is stands for and they probably don't want to think about it at all. Case closed.
 

TommyO'Brien

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
12,228
Fianna Fáil is a classic populist party in the sense that its only policy normally is to follow the crowd, and do what it thinks the public wants, not because it is right but because it is popular.

It has however potentially fatally compromised that appeal by in the 1990s and 2000s becoming a distinctly sectional party, becoming the political wing of builders, bankers and developers. That worked when either the developers had mass support or tolerance, coupled with a form of communal pride in the Celtic Tiger, or when developers' interests were at least marginally similar to popular interest, ie everyone wanted property, wanted to own houses, etc. In the current economic crisis that parallel interest has shattered, leaving bankers, builders and developers' interests conflicting with the perceived interest of voters. Fianna Fáil under Cowen has not been able to dump its cosy cartel with those groups, generating mass public antagonism. The public aren't simply angry with increases taxes, etc. Public opinion can wear harsh measures, but only if they are convinced that those taking the decisions are not protecting those whose interests are contrary to the perceived public interest. People however perceive that FF is still protecting its 'friends' and is willing to shaft ordinary people to protect the interests of its funders.

Lipset and Rokkan, and others, have written how when a political party system emerges (through what is know as 'mass political mobilisation') it is effectively locked in place, which is why parties in many countries tend to be cross-generational and cross-era, reinventing themselves as different public issues arise. FF was always a classic reinvention party (the party that was anti-the treaty worked the treaty; the party that was anti-industrialisation and pro-rural became the party of industrialisation and urban society. The party that was fanatically republican and anti- the Anglo-Irish Agreement became the party of the AIA and the Belfast Agreement, the party that was protectionist became non-protectionist, etc.

However under Lipset and Rokkan, and others there is one thing that sweeps a party into the electoral bin - a failure to evolve and to control its own message. That happened to the Liberals in the UK in the 1920s, happened to the Radicals in France in the 1950s, happened to the Christian Democrats in Italy and the Conservatives in Canada in the 1990s, etc. There is a possibility that such a catastrophic failure may be facing FF this time, for a number of reasons:

1. It had knack of losing power at the right time, being able to oppose cuts on the basis of populism and then return to power when public opinion was ready for cuts. Its Waterloo may ironically have been in 2002 this time. FG lost so many seats it needed to climb not one but two political everests to get into power in 2007. While Kenny achieved the highest comparative seat increase in political history, beating the records of de Valera, Lynch, O'Malley and Spring, it still was not enough, by a tiny amount, to deliver government. So FF find themselves in government during a massive recession and so find the conflict between their populism and their links with bankers, developers and monied supporters.

2. They have an indecisive leader who avoids taking leadership stances in the way other international leaders have done - ie, no message to the nation, no openness, a constant feeling of drift and indecision.

3. The fact that the PDs plus McCreevy dragged FF off its 'follow the people' appeal and into right wing economics, a division exposed in the collapse of the Celtic Tiger when a series of fatal mistakes, most notably overheating the economy to boost party supporting builders and developers, etc.

4. A disintergrating local organisation. A party once a by-word for local on-the-ground has through complaicency linked to Celtic Tiger arrogance ('we are brilliant. We led the country into the boom. We know what we are doing. Critics should commit suicide' etc).

5. Radical change within its main rival Fine Gael, who under Kenny went from being a niche party (large farmers and the wealthy) to being the dominant party among young people, has a massive working class support base (!!!) and re-vitalised organisation, helping to grow into the 30s and remain there, whereas over the previous 30 years FF went from being a party in the 40s to hit the 30s (two elections saw it at 39%, in 1992 and 1997), followed by freefall through the thirties and in polls down to the mid 20s and below. (Political scientists used to say FF could not go below 37%, then 34%, then pollsters said FF had 30% minimum guaranteed. On current poll numbers even hitting 30% is now unlikely!)

So arguably FF nows fit the pattern for one of those catastrophic meltdowns so rare in politics worldwide and which only happen in very exceptional circumstances.

I had always presumed FF was a cert to be the dominant party in Ireland. For the first time looking at what happened in places like Italy, Canada, France etc I am beginning to wonder whether FF's position as the dominant player is in doubt, with Cowen in effect as the John Dillon of the party, taking over a party far less strong in reality than perceived, and drifting from dominance to marginalisation. It is worth noting that FF achieved dominance in the period 1930-36, when then depression so damaged the previously main party, Cumann na nGaedhael, that it allowed the second-placed party, Fianna Fáil, to overtake it and maintain that dominance, with Cumann na nGaedhael, and later Fine Gael, going into longterm decline, producing a one-time party of government that by 1948 was down into the teens in support. It is ironic that FF are in such severe trouble in the biggest economic crisis since the 1930s. (Curiously, every big economic collapse produced a realignment. The 1817-1830 crash produced the O'Connellite movement. The late 1870s-1880s banking crash produced the Home Rule party and led Parnell to dominance within it following William Shaw's desposition in 1880 - Shaw ended up being made Bankcrupt when his Munster Bank collapsed some years later - and the realignment in Free State politics in the 1932 election following the impact in Ireland of the depression.

Statistically Ireland is only 3% off a full depression, and the budget is likely to depress the economy by greater than 3%. So the biggest collapse since the 1930s could produce another political realignment.
 

wysiwyg

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
366
I'll give you an example...

There is one FF councillor down here, who responds to every question with

"what do you think yourself"

eg should Ireland vote Yes to Lisbon... "what do you think yourself"

once the person responds, whether positive or negative, the councillor will then agree with him... and the person will go away feelign vindicated
 

dmc444

Active member
Joined
Feb 6, 2009
Messages
193
Im an FF member and here are a few of many reasons why i support the party.

Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north.

Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.

For me Fianna Fail just was a party to which i could look and say thats what i believe in. Fianna Fail is a broad church which includes many different groups but i believe that is a strength, it is never a bad thing to have different groups expressing differing points of view.
 

Ecoguy

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 12, 2009
Messages
393
I
Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.

.
If FF is so pro EU, why is Ireland the tardiest country in the block when it comes to implementing directives on the environment and human/workers rights etc.??????:mad:
 

Dreaded_Estate

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
3,719
Im an FF member and here are a few of many reasons why i support the party.

Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north.

Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.

For me Fianna Fail just was a party to which i could look and say thats what i believe in. Fianna Fail is a broad church which includes many different groups but i believe that is a strength, it is never a bad thing to have different groups expressing differing points of view.
All the main parties want Ireland to be at the heart of Europe, not something that separates FF from the rest.
 

Raketemensch

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
3,128
Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north.

...........

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.
The peace process has been very successful in ending almost all of the political violence related to the partition of Ireland. It also makes a united Ireland very unlikely any time soon because nobody is suffering with the status quo now. Don't get me wrong, I consider peace to be much more important than national sovereignty over part of the landmass, I'm just pointing out the contradiction.
 

Mr.De-Regulation

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 16, 2008
Messages
455
Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north.

Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.
Right so you follow FF because they adopt FG policies a few years later?
 

Mr.Ograff

Active member
Joined
Oct 30, 2008
Messages
139
To me Fianna Fáil means

Being part of Irelands largest and most successful party

A party that was crucial in the Peace Process

A party that over the decades has protected and looked after the vunerable (although we've lost sight of that in the last 10 years). Fianna Fáil will always be seen as the first party to support our older population, the small farmer and the less well off.

Europe: Ireland is/was at the forefront of European affairs thanks to some FF members. Fianna Fáil is Irelands most known party outside of our waters.

Community: Fianna Fáil thrives to support a sense of community in rural and urban areas

Irish Heritage and Culture: Fianna Fáil has always supported the promotion of Irish Culture. It has promoted the Irish language throughout the country and helped fund our national games.

Fianna Fáil stands for Republicanism (although bit outdated now). Our party was founded on the basis of a treaty supported by a small majority in 1920's Ireland. The supporters of this treaty imprisoned 11,000 people for not supporting the treaty, tortured over 300 and executed almost 100 without substantal grounds.

Our party saw that the only way peace could be brought to our nation was by entering parliament. Fianna Fáil under the leadership of de Valera dismanteled the Anglo Irish Treaty giving us more independance.

Fianna Fáil is a community in itself. All sectors of society are seen in Fianna Fáil and the reality is 99% of members aim to benefit the country however a few bad apples over the years have spoiled it for the rest. However ask anyone involved in grassroots Fianna Fáil and they'll tell you the enjoyment they get out of it.
 

CookieMonster

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 19, 2005
Messages
34,801
The national anthem.
 

oceanclub

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
1,304
Website
oceanclub.blogspot.com
Im an FF member and here are a few of many reasons why i support the party.

Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north.

Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.

Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that.
Um, but for the last two points, most major parties in the Republic believe exactly the same.

So you're essentially saying that the only reason you vote for FF is because of the peace process. Fair enough, but (a) the peace process has come to some sort of completition and (b) does FF's handling of the peace process mean you should ignore their complete balls of as far as everything else in Irish society?

P.
 

asset test

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
14,812
Tommy O'Brien, great post!

I agree with most of it, but some of it I have to think about. All in all I think you have it right.

Sheeple Sheeple, when times are good it's fine, otherwise, let's think again, same goes for Government, don't give the bad news, only the good.

Is this the first time that FF have had to cut the standard of living of the ordinary Joe and Jane? Educate me if I am wrong.

And are FF nearly a Government for Life at this stage? Yer man in Algeria comes to mind
 

dmc444

Active member
Joined
Feb 6, 2009
Messages
193
If you read the beginning of my post i saw they are a few of many reasons.

I have been a member since 2005 and I always have indentified with the party. My political heros are men like Sean Lemass and Albert Reynolds and these are men who inspired me to join Fianna Fail.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2007
Messages
19,091
Fianna Fáil are only a reflection of the selfish, short-termist, and largely unprincipled outlook of at least half the population of the country. Fianna Fáil is only the product of an ingrained culture which has dominated this country for decades, and which has become rather nasty since the last remaining brake on that selfishness - Catholicism - was discarded a couple of decades ago. Fianna Fáil gave those people what they wanted, tomorrow wasn't given a second thought, and this is where we are now. It'll all happen again, and Fianna Fáil will be re-elected again and again. It's Ireland, it'll never change.
 

merle haggard

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2005
Messages
5,497
Im an FF member and here are a few of many reasons why i support the party.

Peace Process- Fianna Fail's work on the peace process has been fantastic and it has delievered huge benefits for the people of the north
you gave irish territory away to the British for good . Thats no different to being a unionist . Partition is a crime and committing treason against the Irish nation as a crime . Fianna fails are a bunch of criminals involved in a treasonous act of criminality against their own nation . Criminals up to their necks in a crime . And a crime that will ensure this island is stuck with conflict that will be much much harder to resolve now that youve dropped articles 2&3 , articles that held out a real hope this conflict could have been put to an end peacefully had you bothered persuing them . But no , you crooks and traitors caved to the brits in return for pats on the back and photo opportunities . Even Haughy wouldnt have done this , which is why you crooks cut his throat and put another crook who would swallow it in his place .
One disgraced leader after another .
Europe- Fianna Fail realises that Ireland needs to be at the heart of Europe in order for us to get the benefit of the union.
so your giving the rest of the country away to foreign powers who want it too .
Republicanism- I believe in the re-unification of Ireland by peaceful means and i believe Fianna Fail can deliever that
according to the Irish constitution put in place by fianna fail there is no country to reunite peacefully or otherwise . The Irish nation only consists of 26 counties . You dropped Irelands sovereign claim to even be a nation and accepted the British claim that the northern territory was part of the British nation instead . Furthermore your constitution doesnt even declare unity desirable much less likely

you lot sold your country down the river , to the brits , to the devlopers , to the banks and to the beuracrats in brussels. And to top it off you put a motorway through tara so spare us the pub patriot horses8it . Your party is a bunch of traitors and criminal whove engaged in the most serious criminal actions against the irish nation .
For me Fianna Fail just was a party to which i could look and say thats what i believe in. Fianna Fail is a broad church which includes many different groups but i believe that is a strength, it is never a bad thing to have different groups expressing differing points of view.
its a bad thing to be a bunch of treacherous , traitorus , barbarian criminal scum , which is all that fianna fail is . Their actions make that abundantly clear .
 

dmc444

Active member
Joined
Feb 6, 2009
Messages
193
Merle- There is now a process for set out by way of referendum for the unification of Ireland also we are now moving forward with a 32 county economy which will removed barriers to a United Ireland, everytime a road is connected up with a North and South we are a step closer to a United Ireland.

Europe- Sure Merle why dont we go like Iceland and go it alone, sure little Ireland can take on China, America and India. We need to be in Europe for prosperity.

Republicanism- You think because Articles 2 and 3 are gone that matters. Its just words, i dont need a constitution or passport to tell me im Irish.

Your last point- I really take issue with people like you on your high horse saying who is Irish and who isnt, I will just tell you this you dont have any right at all to make distinctions like that.
 

Dreaded_Estate

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
3,719
For the next 20 years they will stand for corruption, cronyism and for bringing the country to the brink of default.
 

Raketemensch

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
3,128
Mr. Ograff, thanks very much for your reply, it is in the spirit of what I was looking for in starting the thread and I would like to reply to a few of your points:

To me Fianna Fáil means

Being part of Irelands largest and most successful party
.....
Fianna Fáil is Irelands most known party outside of our waters.
.....
Fianna Fáil is a community in itself. All sectors of society are seen in Fianna Fáil and the reality is 99% of members aim to benefit the country however a few bad apples over the years have spoiled it for the rest. However ask anyone involved in grassroots Fianna Fáil and they'll tell you the enjoyment they get out of it.
I don't understand how joining the majority is in itself a valuable end to pursue. It makes nonsense of normal democratic processes as understood in other western countries, maybe this is the core of the problem with FF as I see it. Its supporters identify that FF=Ireland, why have any political processes at all if that's the case? Perhaps everybody in Ireland should just join FF and express their wishes by voting internally in the party?
 
Last edited:

New Threads

Popular Threads

Most Replies

Top